Fake news: No evidence of ‘baby factories’ in Ukraine

Introduction

Sick: BBC’s fact-checking team have traced false claims of “baby factories” in Ukraine back to a notorious online hoax factory.

“Who would possibly lie about something like that?” you might reasonably ask yourself. Depressingly, we have the answer to that question.

BBC Verify reports:

Several Twitter accounts with a blue tick have recently promoted a claim that Russia has discovered “baby factories” in Ukraine.

Children between the ages of two and seven are said to be “factory farmed”, and either sent to “child sex brothels” or to have their organs harvested and sold in the West.

BBC Verify has traced the origin of the claim to an article published in March by The People’s Voice, an alternative name for YourNewsWire, which has been described by fact-checking organisations as one of the biggest producers of fake news on the internet.

It has previously promoted a wide range of false and misleading stories, including anti-vaccine conspiracy theories and false claims about the 2017 mass shooting in Las Vegas.

The Russian government and Kremlin-controlled media have a history of promoting unsubstantiated claims about illegal organ harvesting in Ukraine.

Hijacking the urge to protect children to produce hatred and justify violence is nothing new.

Old “blood libels” in modern form: These false claims will resonate painfully with Jews around the world – and feel familiar to antisemites. For hundreds of years, Jews were murdered across Europe and the Middle East as a result of blood libels. These are lies claiming that Jews murder and consume the blood of Christian (or Muslim) children for various made-up rites. These rumors persisted despite the fact that religious Jews are strictly forbidden from consuming any blood, in any form.

The “blood libel” refers to a centuries-old false allegation that Jews murder Christians – especially Christian children – to use their blood for ritual purposes, such as an ingredient in the baking of Passover matzah (unleavened bread). It is also sometimes called the “ritual murder charge.” The blood libel dates back to the Middle Ages and has persisted despite Jewish denials and official repudiations by the Catholic Church and many secular authorities. Blood libels have frequently led to mob violence and pogroms, and have occasionally led to the decimation of entire Jewish communities.

Blood Libel: A False, Incendiary Claim Against Jews // Anti-Defamation League, January 9, 2016

Today’s blood libel against Ukrainians – for “farming” babies and children for their organs – just happens to target a country with a Jewish president, Volodymyr Zelensky. As to whether this is a coincidence, or whether this a case of hoaxers and propagandists using fresh versions of old, proven tools to incite hatred – we’ll let you be the judge.


Summary

No, Ukrainians are not “farming” babies for organs or for sex trafficking. These false claims have been traced back to well-known online hoaxers.

Thank you to Shayan Sardarizadeh and the rest of the team at BBC Verify for this reporting.

All sources:

Fact vs Fake tip # 1: Is it the whole story? Cross-reference information. Don't rely on a single source. Check the facts against multiple other sources, especially those that have a different viewpoint. If a claim is true, multiple sources
Making a point about spending on national security, Haley said that the US supporting Ukraine, Israel and securing the southern border would cost "less than 20% of Biden's green subsidies." Facts First: This math from Haley is largely true.
Did Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban tell Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, at the inauguration of Javier Milei as Argentina's new president, that Russian President Vladimir Putin knew something "special" about him? No, that's not true: Orban and Zelenskyy exchanged a
A social media post claims that an accompanying video shows a belly dance performed by the President of Ukraine, Volodymyr Zelenskyy. We check the veracity of the claim in this video. [Verdict: False. The video is a deep fake.]
WHAT WAS CLAIMED: A video shows Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy belly dancing at an event. OUR VERDICT: The footage is not genuine. It has been digitally altered, and President Zelenskyy's face has been imposed onto the dancer's using deepfake techniques.
The caption reads, "When Vladimir Putin and Kim Jong UN met and none of them was willing to drink first." The claim is inaccurate. The video has been edited to remove the moment that they drink. The full video shows
The Verdict: False. There is no evidence that the people of eastern Ukraine were subject to systematic extermination. [...] The claim was spread widely after [Russian Foreign Affairs official] Maria Zakharova [...] stated in February 2022 that there was a
"It's just that YouTube Music published the TOP artists … in Ukraine. Not a single performer in Ukrainian." That is false. Musicians singing in Ukrainian dominated all of YouTube's weekly charts of top artists in Ukraine in 2023 as shown
BOOM found that the video is not real and Volodymyr Zelenskyy's face has been morphed on another dancer's face.
The New York Times did not publish a headline saying Western military experts were bewildered by low civilian casualties in Ukraine. The headline in the circulating screenshot has been altered from an authentic article published by the outlet in late